News

NFL Backup QB Card Market: Mendoza Leads Week 18 Watch

Fernando Mendoza leads the Week 18 NFL quarterback card market watch, with 2026 Topps Chrome Football, J.J. McCarthy RPAs and veteran changes in focus.

NFL Backup QB Card Market: Mendoza Leads Week 18 Watch

We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

Ten NFL teams have made a quarterback change heading into Week 18, but a new starter does not mean the same thing for every player's cards. The Las Vegas Raiders are getting a look at No. 1 pick Fernando Mendoza just as 2026 Topps Chrome Football arrives. The New York Giants are giving J.J. McCarthy a chance to start with a playoff berth still within reach. Other teams are evaluating younger quarterbacks or turning to veterans after injuries depleted the depth chart.

Mendoza has the clearest connection between a change on the field and a new football card release. Multiple sales of his cards have already topped $10,000, however, so the starting opportunity arrives in a market where some buyers have already paid heavily for his upside. Elsewhere, the most concrete card detail belongs to McCarthy, one of only two quarterbacks from the 2024 class with true Panini rookie patch autographs.

Fernando Mendoza starts as 2026 Topps Chrome Football arrives

One trade deadline move helped change the quarterback picture for two teams. Kirk Cousins returned to the Minnesota Vikings and stepped into the starting role there, while Mendoza took over for the Raiders. Minnesota gets a quarterback familiar with the franchise. Las Vegas gets game action from the player it selected first overall.

The timing makes Mendoza the rookie to watch around the release of 2026 Topps Chrome Football. His draft position gave collectors a reason to follow him before he started, and the move into the lineup now gives them regular-season play to evaluate alongside the release. That is a different market setup from a backup getting a brief opportunity on a team that has already settled on its long-term starter.

The reported sales above $10,000 are high-end transactions, not a price guide for Mendoza's cards as a whole. The specific cards and grades behind those sales are not identified, so the figures cannot establish a baseline for his Topps Chrome cards. What they do show is that some collectors were already willing to pay substantial prices before seeing how Mendoza would settle into the job.

Carson Beck's first start ends with an injury

Arizona's quarterback change followed both a trade and an injury. The Cardinals dealt Week 1 starter Jacoby Brissett to Baltimore, and Gardner Minshew was headed to injured reserve. That opened the door for Carson Beck, who was injured in his first start and will miss this week.

Beck had drawn attention in August when he and Carolina Panthers quarterback Haynes King traded good performances in the Hall of Fame Game. That preseason outing raised the question of whether Beck could emerge as a longer-term option for Arizona. His first regular-season start offered a more relevant test, but the injury cut it short.

Outside of Mendoza, Beck is one of the more intriguing potential quarterback chases from the current rookie class. The distinction is that Mendoza has both the No. 1 pick designation and a starting role that coincides with a major release. Beck has an opening in Arizona, but his injury delays the chance to build on it.

Related coverage includes 10 NFL Quarterback Changes Put Rookie Hype and Proven Card Markets on Different Timelines.

J.J. McCarthy brings a distinct 2024 Panini card angle

McCarthy's opportunity with the Giants follows two changes at the position. Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury in Week 2, Jameis Winston took over, and McCarthy has since replaced Winston. The former Michigan national champion appears to have found his footing with New York, one of the few teams in this group still in realistic playoff contention.

McCarthy and Michael Penix are the only quarterbacks from the 2024 class with true Panini RPAs, or rookie patch autographs. That distinction gives McCarthy a specific place in the 2024 football card market that does not depend on a new release. It also applies to those particular rookie cards, not to every McCarthy autograph or memorabilia card.

Where Mendoza's market story pairs a new starter with a current product, McCarthy's is about renewed attention for cards from an earlier rookie class. The Giants' playoff situation adds stakes to his late-season starts, even though the change does not settle the team's longer-term quarterback plans once Dart is healthy.

Anthony Richardson and Drew Lock get another look

Anthony Richardson was the third quarterback selected in 2023, behind Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud, and has an 8-7 record as an NFL starter. He gets another chance in Indianapolis, but the Colts moved much of their offensive talent at the trade deadline. Evaluating Richardson in that lineup means accounting for both his own play and the supporting cast around him.

Seattle's move to Drew Lock comes under different circumstances. Lock began his career in Denver and has outplayed Sam Darnold this season. He now takes over a Seahawks offense that has struggled in the season after a Super Bowl championship. For Lock, the immediate test is whether he can improve an existing offense rather than whether he can establish himself as a rookie.

Richardson's draft position and starting record give collectors a different basis for evaluating his cards than Lock's recent play does. Both have a chance to change how their teams assess the position, but the late-season opportunity by itself offers little certainty about who will be starting next year.

Miami and Philadelphia evaluate Kyle McCord and Joe Milton

The Dolphins are out of playoff contention and expect to have a top-three pick in the next draft. Kyle McCord's late-season opportunity is therefore more about informing an offseason decision than changing Miami's record. If the Dolphins see enough in McCord, they could consider pairing him with a prospect such as Jeremiah Smith. If not, they could use their draft position to address quarterback instead.

Philadelphia turned to Joe Milton after losing Jalen Hurts for the season. Milton previously played for New England and began the year on the Dallas Cowboys' practice squad. His arm strength is a notable part of his profile, and the Eagles now have a chance to evaluate how it translates in their offense.

For the card market, the distinction between those two opportunities is what happens when the season ends. Miami expects to have the draft position to make a significant decision about its offense. Philadelphia needed a replacement for an injured starter. Strong play could help either quarterback make a case for a larger role, but their teams are answering different questions.

Jacoby Brissett and Tommy DeVito fill immediate needs

Baltimore lost both Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley to long-term injuries before turning to Brissett. Undrafted free agent Joe Fagnano got an opportunity, but the Ravens lost consecutive games to Jacksonville and a Los Angeles Chargers team that had entered its matchup 0-8. Baltimore then acquired Brissett, who had opened the season as Arizona's starter.

The move gave Baltimore an experienced option and helped open the door for Beck in Arizona. The same transaction thus created two different hobby storylines: a veteran filling an immediate need for the Ravens and a rookie getting a chance to show whether he could factor into the Cardinals' plans.

New England is turning to Tommy DeVito, who first drew widespread attention during his time with the Giants. The Patriots entered the season with expectations of winning after reaching the Super Bowl the previous year. DeVito has had several NFL opportunities without securing a lasting starting role, so his return to the lineup is more an immediate depth-chart change than evidence that New England has found a long-term answer.

What past quarterback timelines can tell collectors

Several of the hobby's leading quarterback markets belong to first-round picks who play for the teams that drafted them. Those players did not all become starters on the same schedule. Caleb Williams, Joe Burrow and Trevor Lawrence were No. 1 picks who started in Week 1. Josh Allen and Justin Herbert took over during their rookie seasons, while Patrick Mahomes and Jordan Love waited at least a full season before becoming starters.

That range of timelines is relevant to Mendoza because starting later in his rookie season does not put him outside the path followed by established quarterbacks. It is not, however, a projection of his performance or his card prices. His draft status, the timing of his first starts and the arrival of Topps Chrome are identifiable points of interest. The reported five-figure sales show just how high expectations already are at the top end of his market.

The injury-driven changes also leave a separate question for collectors following Jackson and Dart. Their absence gives Brissett and McCarthy playing time, but interest in the injured players' cards depends more on recovery and their roles when they return. For Week 18, Mendoza's performance alongside the Chrome release and McCarthy's play in a live playoff race are the clearest near-term developments to watch. Any price comparison for their cards is most useful when it matches the same card and, where applicable, the same grade.

JJ McCarthy
Jacoby Brissett

Share This Story

Comments

0
  • Sign In