logo
ISA Grading Advertisement

Tom Brady Autograph Event Leaves Collectors Disappointed and Disgruntled

* We may earn a commission from purchases made through our affiliate links.

Screenshot 2024-04-26 132939.png

A special autograph session with Tom Brady, which was part of a larger motivational speaking event in Miami, has resulted in significant dissatisfaction among collectors due to the unexpectedly poor quality of the autographs.

Screenshot 2024-04-26 132912.png

The anticipation surrounding a special autograph session with NFL legend Tom Brady turned to frustration for many collectors last weekend in Miami. The event, held after Brady spoke at a motivational and business conference, included VIP tickets priced at $3,600, which offered attendees a speech, a photo opportunity, and an item signed by Brady himself.

Despite the high expectations, several attendees expressed disappointment with the quality of the autographs provided by Brady. Notably, Brad Jarrett, an avid Brady memorabilia collector, confronted the football star directly, expressing his dissatisfaction with what he described as subpar signatures, especially considering the premium price paid.

The event was managed by EXMA, with promotional efforts led by Fernando Regato, and promised each VIP participant a photo with Brady and an autograph. However, the reality did not meet expectations for collectors like Derek Wagner, who brought multiple high-value items to be signed. Wagner's items included the first Super Bowl touchdown ball from Brady to Rob Gronkowski and several game-used items, all of which received autographs that attendees described as mere scribbles.

Sources close to the event organizers revealed that the contract only guaranteed 100 photos and 100 autographs, specifying that the items to be signed needed prior approval from an authorized vendor—a detail that was reportedly not well communicated to the participants.

The event's aftermath has been tumultuous, with some attendees attempting to reverse their credit card charges or seeking professional help to remove the unsatisfactory signatures. Meanwhile, others, like Greg Nazareth, who also brought significant memorabilia, found the autographs slightly better than others but still below the expected standard.

In the wake of the controversy, Fernando Anzures, founder and CEO of EXMA, acknowledged misunderstandings regarding the autograph session's prerequisites and admitted a lack of familiarity with the intricacies of the autograph market. This miscommunication led to confusion and unmet expectations, tarnishing what was intended to be a premium experience.

The situation was further complicated by chaotic security measures, where attendees were required to deposit their personal items into garbage bags before entering the signing area, adding to the overall dissatisfaction with the event.

Following the event, Wagner sought the expertise of Beckett representatives at SPORTSWORLD to authenticate the autographs. Unfortunately, the results were inconclusive, casting doubt on the authenticity and significantly impacting the perceived value of his collectibles.

This incident has illuminated the challenges and potential pitfalls involved in organizing high-profile autograph sessions, especially when communication and clear guidelines are lacking. For collectors, the event served as a stark reminder of the risks involved in pursuing autographs of this nature.

Share:

PWCC Auction Advertisement

0 Comments

Related

Sports Card News

Sweet Sixteen Showdown: The Cards Heating Up as College Hoops Goes Full Hype Mode


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • March 29, 2025, 3:45 pm

Sweet Sixteen Showdown: The Cards Heating Up as College Hoops Goes Full Hype Mode


March Madness is in full swing, which means two things: buzzer-beaters are back on the menu, and the card market is frothing over with Sweet Sixteen buzz. With scouts lurking in the shadows and fans glued to the screen, this is prime time for young pros...

Read More

Mr Beast Trading Cards Are Now a Thing, Because Of Course They Are


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • March 29, 2025, 3:40 pm

Mr Beast Trading Cards Are Now a Thing, Because Of Course They Are


In a move that surprises absolutely no one paying attention to the current state of internet culture, Topps has jumped headfirst into influencer mania with its latest Topps NOW® drop—this time hitching its collectible wagon to the Sidemen Charity Mat...

Read More

Matas Buzelis Cards Heating Up as Bulls Rookie Breaks Out


  • bionic Avatar
  • by bionic
  • March 25, 2025, 3:45 am

Matas Buzelis Cards Heating Up as Bulls Rookie Breaks Out


Matas Buzelis is starting to look like one of the steals of last year’s NBA Draft—and collectors are taking notice. The 6'10" rookie had a breakout game last Saturday, dropping a career-high 31 points in a blowout win over the Lakers. It wasnâ...

Read More